When the client says “the AI told me”.
For accountants and bookkeepers in practice: get the exact provision, quoted and traceable, so the conversation ends on the Act.
In a December 2025 survey of 500 UK accountants and bookkeepers, 72% had seen more clients using AI outputs to challenge professional advice, 31% met an AI-caused client mistake every week, and half knew of a business that had lost money.
The mistakes cluster where your work does: expenses (46%), VAT (41%), personal tax planning (35%) and payroll (34%). The client is not being difficult. They asked a question, got a confident, well-written answer in seconds, and reasonably wonder why yours is different.
What settles it is not a better opinion. It is the provision.
Source: Dext and Censuswide, December 2025. Commissioned by a software vendor.
Three things on day one
Check a claim against the Act
The client says VAT is charged on something, or is not. Section 4(1) of the Value Added Tax Act 1994 says: “VAT shall be charged on any supply of goods or services made in the United Kingdom, where it is a taxable supply made by a taxable person in the course or furtherance of any business carried on by him.” You quote it. That settles what the Act says. Whether a particular supply is taxable, and by whom, is still your analysis.
Put the source on the file
Each provision comes with the fingerprint of the official file it was read from and the position of its words in that file. A file note that says where the text came from, and when, is an audit trail and not just “I looked it up”.
See the doubt before it bites
Where the publisher’s own two files disagree about a provision, TaxMax marks the field unresolved and shows both. You find out at your desk, not in an enquiry.
What goes on the file
This is a real one, made from the released record of section 4(1). Copy it and see whether it is what your file reviewer would want.
Value Added Tax Act 1994, section 4(1) “VAT shall be charged on any supply of goods or services made in the United Kingdom, where it is a taxable supply made by a taxable person in the course or furtherance of any business carried on by him.” Source: legislation.gov.uk, the publisher’s current view, fetched 14 November 2026. Publisher’s XML, bytes 132648-132649, 132673-132874, file SHA-256 7ff1600a8df7ebcdff5d5660a0c01477cc3edb5daf174669a9cf2a1bb5befdc1 Akoma Ntoso, bytes 2660576-2660579, 2660643-2660646, 2660653-2660851, file SHA-256 5eeeac94b859dd7368f5a98f514138db735231de90fda00df57c079dafdc2f04 The two files agree on this provision. Extent as stated or inherited: E+W+S+N.I.. TaxMax build 4c333e82c849f92ff50f3b6469fa092730eba578242ab2ab79d6c9845f44b5a6, record d156e468028ba34fe85d37c1fb27327c00024acff838b864195d1f49d8ade956 Not an official version; not a statement of the law in force on any date.
What it covers for a general practice today
27 Acts are released: the Value Added Tax Act 1994, the main income tax Acts (ITEPA 2003, ITTOIA 2005, ITA 2007), both Corporation Tax Acts, TCGA 1992, the Capital Allowances Act 2001, IHTA 1984, the Taxes Management Act 1970 and others. The coverage page is the complete list.
What it does not have yet matters to you: the VAT Regulations and other statutory instruments, HMRC’s manuals, and the law as it stood in an earlier tax year. For a question that turns on a regulation or on the position three years ago, it is not there yet, and it will say “not observed” instead of guessing.
TaxMax is not advice and does not replace your judgement or your technical library. It replaces the moment of doubt about whether the words in front of you are the words of the Act.